Blog

Life story editors and writers: the fine line between structural editing and ghost writing

Editors who have done a lot of structural editing – also called “developmental editing” – in the genre of life story, memoir or autobiography will agree that  sometimes their client has needed the editor to not just edit the manuscript, but to do some  life story writing.

When can “editing” a life story cross over into “ghost writing”?

When an editor conducts a “structural edit” their usual role is to provide the author with detailed feedback and suggestions which the author then uses to improve the manuscript through further self-editing and rewriting. That is, the structural editor’s role is not to correct the manuscript for the writer.

However, editors who specialise in memoir or autobiography are sometimes asked to do the hands-on editing and rewriting that the manuscript needs, and this can include rewriting or writing new content. In other words, asked to cross over the line between structural editing and writing.

An editor might cross over into writing if…

It is up to the editor whether or not they agree to do more than simply editing.

The editor might agree to do the rewriting and writing required as well as the  usual editing tasks, if:

  • the editor is also a writer, and
  • the editor decides to offer to do the writing required because (a) for whatever reason it is difficult for the author of the manuscript to do the rewriting and corrections themselves, (b) the author has passed away and their family wants their manuscript to be self-published post-humously, or (c) the person who wants their story published is really looking for a ghost writer, not an editor.

An editor might refer the author to a life story writer if…

Some editors just want to stick to editing and are not interested in crossing over the line into life story writing or, as it is sometimes called, ghost-writing.

When a storyteller or author wants someone to do at least some of the writing for them, but the editor does not want to take on that role, the editor can refer the author to a professional life story writer who is a member of Life Stories Australia.

My experience: editing/life story writing

Some authors write by hand, or self-edit their typed manuscripts in hardcopy. Some authors cannot use a computer, or find using a computer stressful or impossible, due to a disability.

When asked to edit a memoir or autobiography, I first find out whether the author is comfortable using Word and whether they know how to use the Track Changes tool. If they are competent in using Word, I explain the different stages of editing including “structural editing”, and how I can support them as their editor. If they are not able to use Word, they probably need someone  to do the necessary rewriting and writing as well as the editing for them. That is, they need the editor to either cross over the line between “editing” and “writing”,  or refer them to a life story writer.

Because I am both an editor and a life story writer, I often cross over that line. As a result I have produced a number of published memoirs and autobiographies for my storyteller and writer clients – see them here.

Avoiding disputes about authorship and copyright

Whenever I have taken on the dual role of “life story writer” and “editor”,  my model has been that the client (or the writer) is the sole author and copyright owner of the life story. That is, while I have done some of the writing and am recognised as the editor, I am not listed in the book, or in its ISBN metadata, as a writer or co-contributor or co-author of their book.

Other life story writers have different models. Sometimes the life story writer is named as the co-author or author of their client’s life story. Sometimes the writer shares the copyright or royalties with the client.

To avoid problems later on, authors and their editors or life story  writers need to work out and agree to the terms at the outset. The editor or life story writer should explain the options or their requirements around authorship and copyright to the client, come to an agreement with the author, and prepare a contract for the author. I am not a copyright lawyer and have very limited knowledge of copyright issues or contracts, so I will not go into more detail about theose issues here..

About Sally-Anne: structural editor and life story writer

Sally-Anne Watson Kane’s role in writing, editing and producing  memoirs and life stories  sometimes includes life story writing; is sometimes simply editing – structural editing or copy editing. She receives manuscripts of memoirs, family histories and novels from authors who need a structural edit so they can do the further rewriting and editing themselves to improve their manuscript to publication stage. She  receives memoir, autobiography and family history manuscripts from authors who need her to do all the necessary rewriting and writing, as well as the editing. And she is commissioned by clients to write life stories from scratch.

Sally-Anne has been conducting structural edits of memoirs and life stories, writing and compiling memoirs and life stories, and producing self-published books for over 30 years.  She is a professional member of Life Stories Australia and Institute of Professional Editors. For more information have a chat to Sally-Anne via the phone number here.

 


Back To Blog